Kagura are ancient sacred dances from which many Japanese art forms are thought to have evolved. The hill of kagura is Kagurazaka, my neighborhood in Tokyo, famous for great food and good times.


Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Social Consensus


I have lived in Japan long enough to have witnessed the formation of a new social consensus on several occasions.

Years ago, for example, it seemed unimaginable that people here would ever become conscious of the baneful impact of cigarette smoking, much less act on it. In the 1980s, all train platforms had stand-alone ashtrays that would be stuffed to overflow. The worst case would be when a slow burn established itself inside the receptacle, like an underground coal fire. Filters would also burn sending forth toxic plumes that would tolerated by passersby as one of the inevitable aspects of life in Tokyo.

Sometime in the late 1990s, we awoke knowing that smoking was bad and dangerous and should be discouraged. Non-smoking areas proliferated. New language was born: hotaru zoku, the "firefly tribes" huddled outside their offices illuminating the night with the glow of the butt ends. New norms and mores took hold. Unlike the long and highly visible legal and legislative battles in the U.S., in Japan it was not clear how and by whose hand this change came about. But it happened and was one day undeniably evident.

A similar change took place some years back regarding the use of cell phones in public. Years ago, when they were new, and there was some status attached to their possession, it was common enough to see their loud, even ostentatious use. Then, small signs with a cell phone circled and crossed in red started appearing in coffee shops and hotel lobbies. Requests to keep them on silent mode (and off completely near the elderly/disabled seats where they might interfere with pacemakers) were broadcast in trains. The trains today are filled with rows of people, heads down, earnestly texting.

In this case the process and the forces driving it were more visible, but the moment of consolidation was no less dramatic. There is a sense, at least to the foreigner, of something profoundly organic.

Here I will issue a prediction. In the not-distant future a consensus will form—magically, organically—regarding the undesirability of the automobile. With massive and continuing investments in public transport, especially trains and subways, Tokyo and other major cities have become spaces where cars are neither necessary nor convenient. Any real reduction in the prevalence of cars would result in a dramatic improvement in the quality of life here, as well as the city's carbon footprint. It would be great to see many more large-scale pedestrian plazas such as Time Square and (coming soon?) 34th Street and Unions Square in New York. But there are also any number of small backstreets in Tokyo that are useless and/or dangerous as through-streets. My dream is to see these closed off except for emergency vehicles and lined with potted trees creating a vast network of miniature parks that would bring benefits to far greater than any inconvenience.

There are entrenched forces militating against this. There is of course the objective importance of the automotive industry within the Japanese economy as a whole, as well as its concentration in certain regions; the global success of the industry is a source of national pride; the car continues to function as a sign of personal success. This last factor probably looms larger than one might imagine. The people living on the backstreets are often in single family homes of which the car park is a vital aspect. Overcoming this resistance will require a generational change, which would appear to be well underway. In the early 1990s, more than 2.5 million people graduated from the drivers’ schools whose attendance is required to gain a license. In 2007, that number had dropped to less than 1.8 million and the loss of interest in cars and driving continues.

There are physically few cars on the streets of Tokyo today, but the social consensus supporting and accelerating this has yet to form.

But it will. Perhaps once the big auto manufacturers have switched over to making solar panels…